Misrepresentations Prove Costly in IT Contract

A recent case heard by the High Court demonstrates the risks associated with making inaccurate claims when tendering for contracts.

The case involved British Sky Broadcasting Ltd. (Sky) and IT firm Electronic Data Systems Ltd. (EDS). Problems with the integration of Sky's customer relationship management system led it to cancel its contract with EDS. However, Sky subsequently discovered that EDS had made false representations about the analysis it had done as part of the tender process under which it was awarded the work.

Mr Justice Ramsey ruled, after a six-year legal battle, that EDS had made dishonest representations during the tender process and had made further negligent misrepresentations during the course of the project itself.

The damages are expected to exceed £200 million. Although EDS had a limitation of damages clause in its contract with Sky, this will be void because of the fact that the representations on which Sky relied were dishonestly made.

The moral of the story is that when tendering or contracting for work, make sure the claims you make are honestly made – or be prepared for the consequences if things go wrong.

The contents of this article are intended for general information purposes only and shall not be deemed to be, or constitute legal advice. We cannot accept responsibility for any loss as a result of acts or omissions taken in respect of this article.

Ask a free legal question

Complete this simple form if you
would like to ask us a
free legal question
 

What Our Clients Say

We would like to thank you for the superb work and attention to detail that has gone into our dispute with the council so far! 

Our Architect put together a very professional document which was further enhanced and polished by your very professional input. 

You are in fact unique in my personal experience of the legal profession in that you take your duty of care very seriously. It is obvious that the outcome concerns you greatly and your determination to win is much appreciated!

Thank you from us both. 

Best Regards
 
Mr and Mrs X, Surrey